Page 29 - Fall2020
P. 29

THE OFFICIAL STORY                        concept of vaccination. He prepared two groups   The germ
               Bacillus anthracis is a rod-shaped, gram-  of twenty-five sheep, one goat and several cattle.
            positive, facultative anaerobic bacterium about  The animals of one group were twice injected   theory
            1 by 9 μm in size. The bacterium normally rests  with an anthrax vaccine prepared by Pasteur,  allowed
            in spore form in the soil and can survive for  at an interval of fifteen days; the control group   scientists to
            decades in this state.                    was left unvaccinated. Thirty days after the
               Anthrax is spread by contact with the bac-  first injection, both groups were injected with a   envisage a
            terium’s spores. Anthrax spores often appear  culture of live anthrax bacteria. All the animals  quick fix to
            in infectious animal products. Contact is by  in the unvaccinated group died, while all of the   disease with
            breathing, eating or through an area of broken  animals in the vaccinated group survived.
            skin. Anthrax does not typically spread directly   This apparent triumph, widely reported in   a vaccine.
            between people or animals—in other words, it  the local, national and international press, made
            is not contagious.                        Pasteur a national hero and ensured the accep-
               Although a rare                                              tance of vaccination
            disease, human an-                                              in the practice of
            thrax, when it does                                             medicine.
            occur, is most com-                                                That’s the of-
            mon in Africa and                                               ficial story, anyway.
            central and southern                                            Now, let’s examine it
            Asia.  Anthrax  in-                                             more closely.
            fection on the skin
            is known as “hide-                                              PUBLIC VERSUS
            porter’s disease.”                                              PRIVATE
            Historically, inhala-                                              Pasteur’s pub-
            tional anthrax was                                              lic  triumphs look
            called “woolsorter’s                                            different when we
            disease” because it                                             compare the glowing
            was an occupational                                             newspaper reports
            hazard for people                                               of the day with Pas-
            who sorted wool.             Spores of Bacillus anthracis.      teur’s private note-
            Today, this form of                                            books, analyzed by
            infection is extremely rare in advanced nations,  Gerald L. Geison in his book The Private Sci-
            as almost no infected animals remain. In 2008,  ence of Louis Pasteur.
                                                                        2
            a drum maker in the United Kingdom who       Pasteur promoted the theory, widely dis-
            worked with untreated animal skins died from  puted at the time, that microbes caused most
            inhalation anthrax.                       if not every disease. The germ theory allowed
                            1
               While rare today, anthrax posed a major  scientists to envisage a quick fix to disease with
            economic and livestock challenge in France and  a vaccine containing a weakened or attenuated
            elsewhere during the nineteenth century. Sheep  form of the bacteria—similar to the then-com-
            were particularly vulnerable, and national funds  mon idea that a little bit of poison could make
            were set aside to investigate the production of a  you immune to a larger dose.
            vaccine. Louis Pasteur dedicated several years   Reading about these early attempts to find a
            to this quest after Robert Koch, his German  vaccine for anthrax conjures up images of Monty
            rival, claimed discovery of the causative Bacil-  Python and the Ministry of Silly Science. Some
            lus anthracis agent. The efforts to find a vaccine  scientists attempted “attenuation” by subjecting
            enticed not only Pasteur but other scientists of  the microbe to a poison, potassium bichromate,
            his day into a fiercely competitive race for the  or carbolic acid, a disinfectant. Another scientist
            glory and the gold.                       thought he could create an attenuated vaccine
               In 1881, Pasteur performed a public ex-  by heating the blood of infected animals and
            periment at Pouilly-le-Fort to demonstrate his  injecting it into non-infected ones. Some favored

            FALL 2020                                Wise Traditions                                                   27
   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34